Control Charts and Normality

Do You Need to Normalize Data Before Running SPC Charts?...No!

I got a call from a Six Sigma trainer the other day. He asked: Do QI Macros automatically normalize data before creating a control chart? Seems he had a couple of PhDs in his class that seemed to think that you had to normalize data before you do anything. From my point of view, this is silly. You could do a Box Cox transformation of your data, but why bother. Control charts are very robust to non-normal data. Don't believe me? Read Donald Wheeler's discussion of this matter here.

I find that far too many belts try to over complicate the problem solving process. They try to use complicated methods and tools to solve uncomplicated problems. And often, they fail, because they took an overly complicated approach to the process.

What Are We Trying To Do With A Control Chart?

There are two things we want to accomplish with a control chart:

Move the Center Line Up or Down in
Whichever Direction is "Good"
Reduce Variation

control chart improve average

control chart decrease variation

That's it. You don't need to transform the data to do this and it might actually obscure your results.
Use QI Macros Chart Menu to Show Process Changes:

  anatomy of a control chart created by QI Macros for Excel

What Are We Trying To Do With a Histogram?

The same is true of a histogram. What are we trying to do?

Move the Center or Target
Reduce the Variation to
Fit Within the USL/LSL

reduce variation using a histogram

This is true, even if you have non-normal data such as turnaround or cycle times.

Here's a Weibull histogram of time to thrombolitics—drugs that dissolve clots in a heart patient. Clearly non-normal, but which way do we want to move the data? Toward the left! Do you need to normalize this data to use it? No. Can you use a Weibull histogram to display non-normal data? Yes.

weibull-histogram

Here's My Point

Stop obsessing over normality. You don't need to normalize data to draw a control chart or a histogram. You just need to know what you're trying to accomplish through improvement: move the center and reduce the variation.

Are there situations where you will need to normalize data? Sure, but in 25 years of process improvement I haven't needed to do it yet. Stop trying to over complicate the improvement process. It's a terrible and unnecessary form of waste.

Create these charts and diagrams in just seconds using QI Macros for Excel...
Try It Now!