QI Macros vs CHARTrunner Lean®

Ease of Use Step by Step Comparison

Let's compare the two products for ease of use on a simple Individuals Moving Range control chart. If your data is in Excel (which most data is these days), here's how it works.

QI Macros® - $279 USD

1. In Excel, click and drag over your data set to select it.

XmR Data set in QI Macros

2. Click on the QI Macros Menu and select the desired chart or select the Control Chart Wizard if you are not sure which chart to use.

qi-macros-step2-xmr

3. QI Macros will prompt you for chart and axis titles. Just type in the prompts or click ok to use defaults.

QI Macros Chart Title Prompt

QI Macros X Axis Title Prompt

4. QI Macros will draw the charts for you and turn any unstable points or trends red.


QI Macros XmR chart

CHARTrunner Lean® $1,290

1. In CHARTrunner Lean®, click on New Chart:

Chartrunner Lean New Chart

 


2. Edit Chart Type - next click on the chart you want to run.

Choose Chart in Chartrunner Lean

View Larger Image


3. Edit Data Source: Select the type of data from the Data Source menu options:


Chartrunner Lean Data Source

 

4. Edit Data Source (cont): Select the location of the file and the contents to use for this chart.

If Excel, Choose the Data File (Excel Workbook) and Table:

chartrunner lean choose data file

5-8. Edit Data Fields: Select which columns from the data source to use and how the chart should use each column.

Chartrunner edit fields

 

View Larger Image

9. Select Finish and CHARTrunner Lean® will create the charts and turn unstable conditions red.

Chartrunner Lean XmR chart

As you can see, there are a number of additional steps required to achieve the same result. And, as we know from Lean, extra steps mean additional chance for error and more importantly: delay.

The Edit Data Field steps (4 to 8 above) in CHARTrunner Lean® can be confusing.

Comparison of Pareto Chart Output

QI Macros™ - $279 USDpareto chart excel

Bars touch; bars over 20% are highlighted with color; axes are scaled correctly; cumulative percentages are shown on the line graph.

CHARTrunner Lean® - $1,290

chartrunner pareto chart


Bars are close but don't touch. There's no cumulative line graph. So this isn't really a pareto, just a sorted bar chart.


QI Macros Time Savers that CHARTrunner Lean® Does Not Offer

QI Macros Chart Wizards

Many SPC users struggle before they begin with choosing the right chart (Chartrunner Lean® step 1).. That's why the QI Macros have a Chart Wizard and a Control Chart Wizard to choose the right chart automatically. Just select your data and click on the Wizard!

qi-macros-wizards-menu

QI Macros Fill-in-the-Blank Templates

Only the QI Macros has Excel templates for each chart. Just drop your data directly into the yellow input area and the chart is created to the right. You don't have to run anything.

P Chart template

This may be the easiest way to create Excel-based SPC charts that you update every month or week.

But it's up to you. How much money do you have to spend? And how much time and energy do you want to expend creating your charts?

More CHARTrunner Lean® vs QI Macros Comparisons

Create these charts and diagrams in just seconds using QI Macros for Excel...